题目信息

Child development specialists have observed that adolescents who receive large weekly allowances tend to spend money on items considered frivolous by their parents whereas adolescents who receive small weekly allowances do not. Thus, in order to ensure that their children do not spend money on frivolous items, parents should not give their children large weekly allowances.


Which of the following pieces of information would be most useful in evaluating the validity of the conclusion above?

A:The average amount of money received by adolescents who receive large weekly allowances
B:Any differences among parents in the standard used to judge an item as frivolous
C:The educational background of the child development specialists who made this observation
D:The difference between the average annual income of families in which the parents give their children large weekly allowances and that of families in which the parents give their children small weekly allowances
E:The percentage of adolescents who receive no weekly allowance
参考答案及共享解析
共享解析来源为网络权威资源、GMAT高分考生等; 如有疑问,欢迎在评论区提问与讨论
正确答案: B:Any differences among parents in the standard used to judge an item as frivolous

frivolous :- not having any serious purpose or value.


Adolescents--->large weekly allowances-->spend on items not having any serious purpose or value.

Adolescents--->small weekly allowances-->do not spend on items not having serious purpose or value.

The conclusion of the passage is that parents can ensure that their children will not spend money on frivolous items by limiting their children's allowances. This claim is based on the observed difference between the spending habits of children who receive large allowances and those of children who receive small allowances. The argument assumes that the high dollar amount of the allowance – as opposed to some other unobserved factor – is directly linked to the fact that children spend the money on items their parents consider frivolous. Information that provides data about any other factor that might be the cause of the children's spending behavior would help to evaluate the validity of the conclusion.


(B) CORRECT. One alternative to the conclusion of the passage is that the standard used to judge an item as frivolous was much lower for parents who gave their children large weekly allowances than for parents who gave their children small weekly allowances. If for example, the former group of parentsconsidered all movie tickets to be frivolous, while the latter did not, then this fact (and not the difference in allowance money) might explain the difference observed by the child development specialists. Thus, information about any differences among parents in the standard used to judge an item as frivolous would be extremely relevant in evaluating the validity of the conclusion of the passage.


(C) The background of the child development specialists who made the observation has no bearing on the conclusion. The conclusion is based on the observation, not on the credentials of those making the observation.

(D) Family income differences have no clear relevance to the link posited between high allowances and spending on frivolous items

笔记

登录后可添加笔记, / 注册

加入收藏
在线答疑
题目来源
Manhattan
Hi,欢迎来到PAPA GMAT!
课程推荐
备考攻略
Copyright © 2015-2023 上海彼伴网络科技有限公司 沪ICP备2023023608号-2

网站维护公告

因版权方要求,我站部分题库资源将暂停访问,由此给大家带来的不便我们深表歉意。具体恢复时间将另行通知。
请关注趴趴GMAT公众号【趴趴GMAT商科留学】获取最新资讯和其他备考干货;免费集训营和权威公开课亦将循环开设,欢迎各位同学积极报名参加,感谢各位同学的理解和支持。
趴趴GMAT
2019.10.14
确认